FYI...
Sony Copy Protection Called Spyware
-
http://www.techweb.c..._section=700028
November 8, 2005
"Sony BMG's woes over its CD copy protection scheme continued Tuesday as a security company accused the entertainment firm of shoving spyware onto users' PCs. By Computer Associates' account, the XCP (eXtended Copy Protection) technology failed 8 of the 22 tests it applies to determine if software is legitimate or spyware, and so it added the programs to its Pest Patrol spyware lists. "Sony failed several different tests, each of which would have identified it as either a Trojan [horse] or a rootkit," said Sam Curry, vice president of CA's eTrust Security group. XCP -- which was crafted by U.K.-based First4Internet -- has serious spyware personality traits, including a lack of consent, the omission of an uninstall routine, and most egregious, a hidden "phone home" feature that sends data about the user to Sony without the user's permission.
The software retrieves lyrics and updated album art automatically, but also, claimed Curry, the user's IP address. "This could also be used to determine [music] playing habits," said Curry. "And users aren't told any of this." Hidden features and a lack of a clear end-user licensing agreement ( EULA) are traits of spyware, pure and simple, said Curry. "People are buying CDs, thinking they're getting content, when in actuality, the CD's changing the behavior of the user's computer"...
Curry said that his group was also digging into Sony's process for users who request an uninstaller because that has spyware characteristics as well. "The uninstaller is an ActiveX control, which is generally considered a security problem," said Curry, "but the removal process also requires users to give up personal information." That information includes their name, e-mail address, the albums purchased, and the places of purchase.
An unknown amount of data is also sent by the ActiveX uninstaller to First4Internet, claimed Curry, and the copy protection causes the system hard drive to read so frequently that it "becomes nearly constant, and could damage the hardware," he added. "This isn't an issue about artists' rights, it's an issue about users' rights. The computer is more than a gloried CD player"..."